Round 79: Sherlock Holmes Edition [Mafia Win]

Might wanna switch that abstain to a no lynch btw aboi. :/

[vote no lynch]
I got Shadi as not Mafia.

Inb4 everyone's R0 peeks were "not Mafia"

Rain said that everyone got a random "not mafia" result so they should all be not mafia. At any rate, my intel suggests Zink is not mafia and for once, I'll concede that a [vote nolynch] is a vote for victory.

Link Lab wrote:Rain said that everyone got a random "not mafia" result so they should all be not mafia. At any rate, my intel suggests Zink is not mafia and for once, I'll concede that a [vote nolynch] is a vote for victory.

The point is that we know who the peek is on. It enables us (or helps rather) to determine Mafia based on the remaining investigators when Sherlock decides to come out in the open. It also allows us to spot the flaws in Mafia's peeks.

I'll also add that being afk and not submitting a peek every night will be detrimental to the town, regardless of whether or not Mafia get a kill on Sherlock. Furthermore it'd make you appear like Mafia (as it's clearly counter-productive towards towns efforts, especially given that we're not doing any lynching).

French not mafia
[Vote Link Lab]

If everyone gets a non-mafia result then people should say if they are/aren't insane.

[vote no lynch]

Aboithagameboi wrote:If everyone gets a non-mafia result then people should say if they are/aren't insane.

Only problem with that is none of us know if we are/aren't normal, insane, or naive

Aboithagameboi wrote:If everyone gets a non-mafia result then people should say if they are/aren't insane.

[vote no lynch]

Bit of a derp there aboi. Vanilla role doesn't provide any information about what kind of cop you are.

Btw how troll would it be if there were no Mafia and we were just all given not-guilty peeks? :D

Sounds like a solid plan from Monsieur Connections.

My peek says Cael is not mafia
And I'll [vote no lynch], as suggested.

Round ends in under four hours (9PM EST). I neglected to specifically mention the time before, sorry.

I am missing a crapton of night actions. Per the rules, however, we will be ending tonight since over half the players have voted. Best get active, guys.

I got that Cael is not mafia.

Having no lynch seems like a good idea in a logic game.

[vote no lynch]

Round end! No lynch wins the vote.

Link was murdereded. Peek PMs going out shortly. Geno is at risk for modkill if he does not vote next round.

[dusk]
[kill link, shot]
[dawn]

Sorry, yet again, for the lack of story. That's probably going to be pretty standard this game, unfortunately. If anyone wants to write something for the game, I'd more than welcome their help.

I find that Aboi is not mafia

I... Was busy for the past few day. Apologies for my absence. I found that Zyq was not mafia round 1.

I found that French is not mafia.

[vote no lynch]

[Vote no lynch]
Shadi is not Mafia.

I found that French is Mafia
[vote no lynch]

I'm going to try and investigate French again tonight, see if I might be insane and get a different result. I encourage Zyq to do the same.

Caelun_Niveus wrote:I'm going to try and investigate French again tonight, see if I might be insane and get a different result.  I encourage Zyq to do the same.

Note: The Insane Inspector gets inverted peeks. eg, he peeks normal villagers as guilty and mafia as innocent. The two Confused Inspectors will get the random results you seem to be searching for.

I'm bad at the game and forgot to put in my night action

[vote no lynch]

Caelun_Niveus wrote:I'm going to try and investigate French again tonight, see if I might be insane and get a different result.  I encourage Zyq to do the same.

Strangely enough, I think that multiple people identifying the same target is a waste. Especially given that even if you're a confused PI, it might be RNG based. The no-lynch plan revolves around Sherlock revealing your roles after death. If you are a confused townie though it might be worth peeking the same target every round to find out. HOWEVER if it turns out that you're not a confused PI, you're in fact screwing over the town massively.
Strangely enough, the sane and the insane PIs are the most useful town roles (of equal strength) in terms of identifying Mafia, and it should Mafia's priority to kill them or Sherlock first (though Sherlock is more of a late-game role while the PIs are early game).
The Naive PI is useful for finding a safe townie amongst the other players as well as Moriarty.
And the 2 confused PIs are essentially liabilities to the town (not your fault guys; it's the role) and should die asap.
Finally Sherlock is handy for creating mason circles (based on the peeks and death flips, he can have a good idea of who's legit and who's not).
Btw Geno: your peek result please before you die.

Rainboy wrote:

Caelun_Niveus wrote:I'm going to try and investigate French again tonight, see if I might be insane and get a different result.  I encourage Zyq to do the same.

Note: The Insane Inspector gets inverted peeks. eg, he peeks normal villagers as guilty and mafia as innocent. The two Confused Inspectors will get the random results you seem to be searching for.

Noted, my bad. Just got the names mixed up.

Didn't really know who to peek so I peeked French too, and also got French is not mafia.

Are we still doing the [vote no lynch] thing till we work stuff out?
And should we try and co-ordinate who we peek? I feel like we're (mostly) taking shots in the dark.

Zink120 wrote:Didn't really know who to peek so I peeked French too, and also got French is not mafia.

Are we still doing the [vote no lynch] thing till we work stuff out?
And should we try and co-ordinate who we peek? I feel like we're (mostly) taking shots in the dark.

Getting a scum vibe from you tbh my bro. :/ It's pointless co-ordinating, as it allows Mafia to rig the peeks by night killing targets. This round is heavily RNG based in that respect; gotta hope that players roll the dice on the right targets. The mental process comes at R3/4.

Round 2 end!

French was killed. No lynch won the vote.

[dusk]
[kill French, shot]
[dawn]

PMs going out shortly.