Round 19: Turnabout Mafia

Dracojounin7 wrote:

Very nice observation but i'm just gonna say that we both got off lucky in not dieing.

Not sure how you knew this exactly, which is suspicious.

Nanon votan, just in case.

Phoebe - 3 - Mentle, Rofl, DA
DA - 3 - Leo, spplmj, Nyu
Nanon - 3 - Phonics, Vat, Draco
Vat - 2 - Cloak, Nanon
Spplmj - 2 - Link, Aboi
Abstain - 2 - Haru, Gamage

I don't know, i'm just guessing. I'm guessing that we got off lucky and I realized I did not state that in which case i'm a horses ass.

Oh damn... At least the Saulus got offed before something bad happened.
Vat votan for now because lolRNG.

Phoebe - 3 - Mentle, Rofl, DA
DA - 3 - Leo, spplmj, Nyu
Nanon - 3 - Phonics, Vat, Draco
Vat - 3 - Cloak, Nanon, Orion
Spplmj - 2 - Link, Aboi
Abstain - 2 - Haru, Gamage

...we are going to cause RNG screw until we lose this way. I still think that if we are still clueless, Pheonix should go down. If he is guilty he might reveal some partners based on some earlier votes.

Mentle wrote:Pheonix should go down.

But what if Pheonix... is Pheonix?

Mentle wrote:...we are going to cause RNG screw until we lose this way. I still think that if we are still clueless, Pheonix should go down. If he is guilty he might reveal some partners based on some earlier votes.

1. Its Phoenix...

2. Already pushing for someone to die this early in the game? That is a bit reckless, even for me. Now I know I have a rep for these games, but its too early to tell if I will fuck shit up in this round, so its really odd for you to do so. So, I guess its time for some reveal role.

I am in the investigator. Last night I had investigated Nanon. He came out guilty. Of course, we don't know if it was tampered with or not, but the Bus Driver had died in the night as well, so chances are Nanon was not involved at all. And round one is mostly RNG, so nothing suspicious there. So, today I voted against Nanon based on my assumption and investigation. Then Mentle immediately jumped to vote on me, without reason in a similar manner to me. That makes me believe that Mentle is out to get me to save Nanon since they both may very well be inside the Mafia. This also makes me believe that Vat is innocent, mainly because that Nanon and Vat both vote each other every first round, they could both be innocent or on separate sides. If they were both Mafia, then they wouldn't go for that. Or, they kept tradition. Not sure.

So, with all of that, Mentle you should really watch yourself before jumping in on an accusation like that. But an RNG vote is always common early in the game, so we wont screw ourselves that quickly. We aren't all that stupid.

Vote staying on Nanon. If I die in night kill, then I may be right with this thinking.


Phoenix - 3 - Mentle, Rofl, DA
DA - 3 - Leo, spplmj, Nyu
Nanon - 3 - Phoenix, Vat, Draco
Vat - 3 - Cloak, Nanon, Orion
Spplmj - 2 - Link, Aboi
Abstain - 2 - Haru, Gamage

...Hm... I'll trust you for now since I have nothing else to go off of... but if you're wrong, your head is up next.

Phoenix - 3 - Mentle, Rofl, DA
DA - 2 - spplmj, Nyu
Nanon - 4 - Phoenix, Vat, Draco, Leo
Vat - 3 - Cloak, Nanon, Orion
Spplmj - 2 - Link, Aboi
Abstain - 2 - Haru, Gamage

16/16

Siding with Phoen. His alabi seems legit.

Phoenix - 2 - Mentle, Rofl
DA - 2 - spplmj, Nyu
Nanon - 5 - Phoenix, Vat, Draco, Leo, DA
Vat - 3 - Cloak, Nanon, Orion
Spplmj - 2 - Link, Aboi
Abstain - 2 - Haru, Gamage

16/16

Polls closed, Nanon lynched, story to follow.

So Nanon's fate is pretty much sealed... on the off chance he doesn't get lynched, it should be Vat, whom I also suspect...

Let's just see how Phoenix's lead works out.

"I see you finally came to a decisive decision."


" It looks like the guilty party here is..."


" Matt Engarde!"


"What? Me? That's crazy..."


"Save it, pal, You're sunk."

"W-Wait!"

" Can I get a last phonecall or something?!"



"Hrm...Fine! But make it quick, pal!"

Instead of pulling out his phone, He pulls out his sword, and jams it into gumshoe.
Gumshoe falls and Engarde tries to run for it, He makes it to the door.


"Goodbye, You fools!"

As he opens the door in the lobby, a huge wall of water hits him.
The others quickly close the doors leading out of the lobby, Leaving Matt trapped to drown in the waters.

------------------------------------------------------
Nanon, Matt Engarde Can't swim while indoors

Spoiler:

Pheonix, Gumshoe, had assistance in seppuku.

Spoiler:

Welp, called it. Didn't expect to die though, that was a bit unexpected. Would have made mafia members obvious. Guess the game is really just starting. Good luck guys.

Wait, how did pheonix get killed by nanon?
It doesn't say he's vengeful, and if he's toast, he can't night kill.

Ooh, nice, quick update. And arguably good results. Phoenix was right, but now he's gone...

Judging by how there wasn't a second kill tonight, I suspect some kind of paranoid role rather than a serial killer. Unless a doctor was involved.

Cloak wrote:Wait, how did pheonix get killed by nanon?
It doesn't say he's vengeful, and if he's toast, he can't night kill.

I doubt the mafia would let Nanon carry out the kill if they knew he was going to get lynched, so assuming Stalin didn't mess up, I suspect this.

... eh.
Well, damn.
At least phoenix didn't do anything to actively screw us other than being the guy that died tonight.

*Chalks up another win tally against Nanon*


And now I'm completely satisfied for this round, so I vote for abstain, that bastard.

Abstain - 1 - Vatonnage

1/14

Oh, polls are open?

...Meh, I'm too tired to think. I'll just abstain until I get some rest.

Abstain - 2 - Vatonnage, Leo

2/14

I guess I sided wrong in the Nanon/Vat fight this time.
FORGIVE ME! *commits sudoku*
*doesn't die when killed*
Okay, with that out of the way, abstain for now.

Abstain - 3 - Vatonnage, Leo, Cloak

3/14

Phoenix wrote:
1. Its Phoenix...

We all know it's not.

Phoenix wrote:
Then Mentle immediately jumped to vote on me, without reason in a similar manner to me.

Not really, at the start, when we have nothing to work on, the most reasonable move is to pick little details and risk, since I'd be voting for a random person anyway and abstaining gives more control to the mafia. When we had Aboi and Zyq tied with 3 votes in the first day, you made it a three way tie by voting DA simply for the RNG screwage, and that would be a great excuse if you wanted to save either Aboi or Zyq from being lynched without seeing obvious (I know RNG screwage is cool, but keep that in mind). Without anyone else in my mind I was going to risk lynching you, and in case you were scum I could move against Aboi.

Fortunately you decided to reveal your role only after you got one name, but since it's late and the bus driver is dead, it seems that there was no doctor to protect you.

Phoenix wrote:
This also makes me believe that Vat is innocent, mainly because that Nanon and Vat both vote each other every first round, they could both be innocent or on separate sides. If they were both Mafia, then they wouldn't go for that. Or, they kept tradition. Not sure.

...they ALWAYS vote for each other at the start of EVERY round, if they were mafia and did it any different this time, they would be calling for a lynch. I don't think we can take any conclusions out of what they always do.

And with that, Aboi votan. I know Phoenix wasn't protecting him, but I got another reason too suspect Marcus' lover.

Aboi - 1 - Mentlegen
Abstain - 3 - Vatonnage, Leo, Cloak

4/14

Welp I died, good job Phoenix. Now you free'd me up to do other things see ya'll n-

Vatonnage wrote:*Chalks up another win tally against Nanon*


And now I'm completely satisfied for this round, so I vote for abstain, that bastard.

AKJFHKJAsHLFJLAKHJAKLJHDFKJSDHGVADHJGEJHNGKWJHGKEJKW YOU ARE THE NEXT PERSON ON MY TO KILL LIST KJASNFKJKFLGJHSKJKAKJALHHJJH

Wow.... will this meddlesome war never end?
Most likely not.

Otherwise I shall throw down my vote upon suspect Mentlegen!

Mentle - 1 - Nyu
Aboi - 1 - Mentlegen
Abstain - 3 - Vatonnage, Leo, Cloak

It's 2 in the morning so my judgement may not be the best but I think I'll vote Aboi, since he actually uses Marcus.

Mentle - 1 - Nyu
Aboi - 2 - Mentlegen, Rofl
Abstain - 3 - Vatonnage, Leo, Cloak

Oh hey, we got the Usurper. Also, if there's 5 non-townies like Stalin claimed in the mafia chat, that means we have an unaccounted fourth party or third party member. So I'm almost certain one of them can kill and was interfered with last night.

Gonna vote Orion.

Mentle - 1 - Nyu
Aboi - 2 - Mentlegen, Rofl
Orion - 1 - Link
Abstain - 3 - Vatonnage, Leo, Cloak

Alright, now that I got some sleep, let's vote for Aboi.

Mentle - 1 - Nyu
Aboi - 3 - Mentlegen, Rofl, Leo
Orion - 1 - Link
Abstain - 2 - Vatonnage, Cloak

7/14

Abstain, for the time being.

Mentle - 1 - Nyu
Aboi - 3 - Mentlegen, Rofl, Leo
Orion - 1 - Link
Abstain - 3 - Vatonnage, Cloak, Draco

8/14

After a night of sleep I actually read the update, and my reasoning to vote Aboi is kind of ruined now, even if I'm not sure if he's really innocent, so I'm taking my vote off him.

I don't know if Engarde making the kill even though he was lynched is part of Stalin's plan or he just didn't use the identity of the real killer, but Alba and Engarde are members of the same group, yet both killed someone on the first night (what fortunately cost Engarde's godfather powers and let Phonix get him). It was either a quite OP mafia where two could make a move or Alba's EXTRATERRITORIAL RIGHTS ARE TOO POWERFUL TO LET HIM GET TARGETED BY ANY NIGHT ACTIONS, and we lost the bus driver who tried to switch him.

What I'm really worried about is Shelly de Killer. Maybe he was a vigilante with the objective of getting rid of Engarde, maybe he's a survivor, but then again something could bring back him to his old job as a serial killer.

Mentle - 1 - Nyu
Aboi - 2 - Rofl, Leo
Orion - 1 - Link
Abstain - 4 - Vatonnage, Cloak, Draco, Mentlegen

8/14